Teachers and Students > Debates

Taxes and Charity?! WHAT's THE DIFFERENCE?!!!

<< < (7/17) > >>

Alpha:

--- Quote from: Arsenal<3 on June 15, 2010, 03:37:31 am ---In a capitalistic society where every member gets what he deserves according to his ability ,why should that person donate.Government should provide education for all be it poor or rich but thats where the role should finish. After that it depends on the person and his ability to afford what he wants

--- End quote ---

For the government to give money, it should first be having the funds. And poverty is not a priority, a government may be having other projects as well. AND people claim to be dependent, then why when they have problems they should always hope for the government to help? Where does the money come?

$tyli$h Executive:

--- Quote from: ~Alpha on June 16, 2010, 03:19:44 pm ---For the government to give money, it should first be having the funds. And poverty is not a priority, a government may be having other projects as well. AND people claim to be dependent, then why when they have problems they should always hope for the government to help? Where does the money come?

--- End quote ---

But those 'other projects' are mostly for the benefit of poor people! :-\

For example,

1. Subsidizing sugar mills - mostly poor people are the workers over there. They benefit.

2. Building roads and bridges in rural areas - mostly used by poor people.

3. Microcredit schemes - only for poor people willing to start a business.

MANY more.

So, if I give tax, I help poor people (the above are just a few ways). So, taxes = Charity.

$tyli$h Executive:
~Alpha     08:41:13 PM   Viewing Who's Online.

~Alpha     08:44:18 PM   Viewing the topic Taxes and Charity?! WHAT's THE DIFFERENCE?!!!.

She's still viewing it... Don't know when she'll post. ::)

Alpha:

--- Quote from: $tyli$h Executive on June 16, 2010, 03:38:23 pm ---But those 'other projects' are mostly for the benefit of poor people! :-\

For example,

1. Subsidizing sugar mills - mostly poor people are the workers over there. They benefit.


--- End quote ---

Giving poor people low order level jobs will help them? Prices are also rising... remember.
Do you think subsidies are efficient tools? I see them as a paralyzing factor.


--- Quote ---2. Building roads and bridges in rural areas - mostly used by poor people.
--- End quote ---

That does not bring them food, shelter and clothing-- the basics.


--- Quote ---3. Microcredit schemes - only for poor people willing to start a business.
--- End quote ---

Rich people would work and tire themselves out to hell for their tax money to be given to the poor ones who are going to set up small businesses, sell at lower prices, take away their consumers and increase competition?


--- Quote ---MANY more.

So, if I give tax, I help poor people (the above are just a few ways). So, taxes = Charity.
--- End quote ---

Are you?

Alpha:

--- Quote from: $tyli$h Executive on June 16, 2010, 03:42:38 pm ---~Alpha     08:41:13 PM   Viewing Who's Online.

~Alpha     08:44:18 PM   Viewing the topic Taxes and Charity?! WHAT's THE DIFFERENCE?!!!.

She's still viewing it... Don't know when she'll post. ::)

--- End quote ---

Who pays you to spy on me?  :P

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version