You are both correct.
How come?
See, that's what I understood, correct me if I'm wrong!
In CH
3CH=CH
2, the alkyl group is present on the LHS so it electrons are pushed to the RHS due to the Induction effect, so a carbocation is formed at the LHS and so Br
+ which is more reactive than Na
+ will attach to the slightly negatively charged carbon atom i.e. the one of the RHS and now what's left is the Br
- and the Cl
-, so they'll have to attach to the carbocation which is positively charged since they are negatively charged, right? & not on the RHS where the carbon atom is negatively charged.
& also, another question:
What was the original alkene before it got oxidised in the presence of hot acidic KMnO
4 and produced CO
2 + CH
3COCH
2CH
3 + CH
3COCH
3 + CH
3COOH + H
2O?