Teachers and Students > Debates
Who's is Kashmir rightfully
XaM!!:
no its wrong.... bangladesh ppl wanted independncy... becuz there vr sum reasns....... first ws is the distance btween pakistan n bangladesh... secondly riots startd by indians... thirdly accomodation prob in bangladesh because main offices ver in Pakistan...... fourthly elections were held where Awami Party won n wanted a seperate country....
And where as Kashmir is concernd if you remember abt Hyderabad the ruler was Muslim and it wantd 2 join Pak but da ppl ver Hindus... So he decided 2 join India... Same shud hav happend to Kashmir.... India became greedy n waged war also later on....
nid404:
--- Quote from: SnEaKrzzz NyTe...... on June 11, 2009, 07:05:27 pm ---no its wrong.... bangladesh ppl wanted independncy... becuz there vr sum reasns....... first ws is the distance btween pakistan n bangladesh... secondly riots startd by indians... thirdly accomodation prob in bangladesh because main offices ver in Pakistan...... fourthly elections were held where Awami Party won n wanted a seperate country....
And where as Kashmir is concernd if you remember abt Hyderabad the ruler was Muslim and it wantd 2 join Pak but da ppl ver Hindus... So he decided 2 join India... Same shud hav happend to Kashmir.... India became greedy n waged war also later on....
--- End quote ---
I have stated that reason somewhere above...India was dragged into the controversy. Well.. one of them who created the problem(the partition)-Gandhi(he was not bad) was shot and the other (Jinnah..I don't know abt him)one was stabbed. So long after they r gone, we r still fighting :(
godfather93:
--- Quote from: SnEaKrzzz NyTe...... on June 11, 2009, 07:05:27 pm ---no its wrong.... bangladesh ppl wanted independncy... becuz there vr sum reasns....... first ws is the distance btween pakistan n bangladesh... secondly riots startd by indians... thirdly accomodation prob in bangladesh because main offices ver in Pakistan...... fourthly elections were held where Awami Party won n wanted a seperate country....
And where as Kashmir is concernd if you remember abt Hyderabad the ruler was Muslim and it wantd 2 join Pak but da ppl ver Hindus... So he decided 2 join India... Same shud hav happend to Kashmir.... India became greedy n waged war also later on....
--- End quote ---
Hey, if we go on like this then we'll talk about west punjab, hindu majority and sikh majority cities in Pakistan.
And the main thing to remember is that the whole place used to be the Indian subcontinent.
godfather93:
--- Quote from: SnEaKrzzz NyTe...... on June 11, 2009, 07:05:27 pm ---no its wrong.... bangladesh ppl wanted independncy... becuz there vr sum reasns....... first ws is the distance btween pakistan n bangladesh... secondly riots startd by indians... thirdly accomodation prob in bangladesh because main offices ver in Pakistan...... fourthly elections were held where Awami Party won n wanted a seperate country....
And where as Kashmir is concernd if you remember abt Hyderabad the ruler was Muslim and it wantd 2 join Pak but da ppl ver Hindus... So he decided 2 join India... Same shud hav happend to Kashmir.... India became greedy n waged war also later on....
--- End quote ---
and even if there were riots by indians, why do u think they took place? it is because they were being killed and genocide was taking place.
angell:
All things considered : Kashmir would be safer in india's hands.
And who doesnt want the heaven India is as home :)
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version