These is how I review this forum after spending some time here.
Things that are good.
1. Academic users. As can be expected from a student forum, the members are all intelligent and intellectual and seldom not. I have been pleasantly surprised by the new knowledge I have gained from discussion with some of the users.
2. Helpful members, dedicated to assisting other users. Especially the section on Maths and Physics.
These are what makes the forum worth coming back to over and over again.
Things that are bad.
1. The user interface. With all due respect, the interface would be appealing if this was 2006. As of now compared to similar forums it's dull and boring. If given the opportunity I could use my knowledge to suggest how it could be improved. As it is right now, I don't see why it would appeal to a potential new member over another similar site. And with the fact that this has a GCE past paper website attached to it, it's surprising why it isn't nowhere as popular as it should be. This is what mainly bothered me, as this site has tremendous potential.
3. The descriptions of each of the sub forums is dated.
This is mainly aimed at people who run the website to ponder on, and any thoughts or scorn from other members are welcome but unnecessary.