IGCSE/GCSE/O & A Level/IB/University Student Forum
Student Forum => Help, Complaints and Suggestions. => Topic started by: Chingoo on September 07, 2010, 01:47:34 am
-
I want some clarification of the Site Rule:
No More discussing about Religions anywhere in this Forum!
I have seen discussions pop up on the forums concerning religion, though not of a negative nature. I did participate in them, and then the moderator(s) tended to delete the thread and that was quite about it.
I'm not the one to be a backseat moderator, but the fact that not once was I informed in PM or otherwise that such threads will get me in trouble or something, and that these discussions continue to spring up is a bit confusing.
Is it allowed to discuss religion or not? If yes, then to which extent? If not, then why are people who make these discussions, and participants, not warned/penalized in any way? I realize I could be indirectly asking for a punishment :P But it'd help so I know what to do and what not to do for future reference.
Thank you in advance.
-
Nobody Debates about Religion.
Except me.
So if i have started a thread, Usually it will end up in a bin or utter tosh.
-
To be frank, we're ourselves having a discussion about this in the lounge.
How I see it: You can bring in religion as far as it does not offend your interlocutor or anyone else.
That's normally how it is. But what's difficult is to determine how far can a simple comment offend others.
-
To be frank, we're ourselves having a discussion about this in the lounge.
How I see it: You can bring in religion as far as it does not offend your interlocutor or anyone else.
That's normally how it is. But what's difficult is to determine how far can a simple comment offend others.
Well, atm some moderators (I can't say who since I don't know who :P) are going by the principle of removing any religious discussion at all. So I suppose I'd request the administration and management to speed up the decision process. :D Good luck.
-
Well, atm some moderators (I can't say who since I don't know who :P) are going by the principle of removing any religious discussion at all. So I suppose I'd request the administration and management to speed up the decision process. :D Good luck.
You don't want religion to come into the forum at all?
-
I WANT T_T ..Srsly :'(
-
I WANT T_T ..Srsly :'(
Yeah, sometimes, we just cannot avoid.
Nway, the mods and admins will decide.
-
You cannot avoid religion if you want to participate In debates .
Generally in Countries like America or Provinces like Dakota North of America there seems to be no debate about religion at all, however we in Asia particularly in Middle east, birthplace of 3 of the world's largest religions, religion dominates our every day routine so no matter what topic you will be discussing it will always come down to whether it is correct in your religion or not.
Peace
-
You don't want religion to come into the forum at all?
I didn't say that. :-\ I said some moderators remove religious discussions in which no one is offending anyone at all. I mean, a member posted asking if drawing human or animal figures was allowed in Islam, and all that happened was that I posted a couple of references to guide him/her. And apparently, the moderators removed that too.
In fact, religious discussions are a great way to bond sometimes because religion plays an important--or at least a background--role in most people's lives. Also, seeing we belong to the Asian/African part of the world mostly, most of us are not atheist or nonpracticing. :P
-
You cannot avoid religion if you want to participate In debates .
Generally in Countries like America or Provinces like Dakota North of America there seems to be no debate about religion at all, however we in Asia particularly in Middle east, birthplace of 3 of the world largest religions, religion dominates our every day routine so no matter what topic you will be discussing it will always come down to whether it is correct in your religion or not.
Peace
Very correct.
-
I didn't say that. :-\ I said some moderators remove religious discussions in which no one is offending anyone at all. I mean, a member posted asking if drawing human or animal figures was allowed in Islam, and all that happened was that I posted a couple of references to guide him/her. And apparently, the moderators removed that too.
In fact, religious discussions are a great way to bond sometimes because religion plays an important--or at least a background--role in most people's lives. Also, seeing we belong to the Asian/African part of the world mostly, most of us are not atheist or nonpracticing. :P
Oh okay... Now I see where you want to reach.
Thank you for bringing that up. :)
-
We can't be judgmental. I'm not someone who wishes to discuss religion openly. I'm very much Asian :P And there are many others who I know don't like to.
And debating with religion is not rational debating. It is not the beliefs that earn you points in a debate, it's the reality and practicality that does. :)
Now why we don't like allowing religious discussions is because we are primarily an educational forum. Our main aim is to help students academically. Our purpose cannot be hidden under religious discussions.
Religion can be discussed via pms, no restrictions. :) You are FREE to wish people on religious occasions, no problems. We are a multicultural forum and we like to see no divide.
We are still discussing the extent to which discussion should be allowed. For now, no discussions please. We've had problems in the past and I think we need to avoid a repeat. We cannot be decisive in such issues.We expect to take some time to finalize on things. We kindly ask you to cooperate :)
And the thread you are talking about, we have sent the author of the thread a message and your responses were sent along too :)
-
Is it allowed to discuss religion or not? If yes, then to which extent? If not, then why are people who make these discussions, and participants, not warned/penalized in any way? I realize I could be indirectly asking for a punishment :P But it'd help so I know what to do and what not to do for future reference.
Thank you in advance.
The ones who discuss cannot be penalized heavily until they have hurt religious sentiments of others.
If it's just a casual discussion, we send them a pm telling them why their thread had to be moved. This is not considered as a warning. Just a reminder. :)
-
In short :
1.) Debating and discussing religion is forbidden
2.) You CAN post threads where you wish each other Eid Mubarak/Merry Christmas etc.
3.) Regarding religious ADVICE - we have yet to decide.
-
Thank you Garfield and Ari for clarifying things. I hope you reach a conclusion soon on the matter of religious advice. :)
-
Thank you Garfield and Ari for clarifying things. I hope you reach a conclusion soon on the matter of religious advice. :)
We have to wait for Astar to make the final decision.
-
hmm......i kindly request the board to critically analyse the situation before reaching a verdict!
This is an open forum and anything should be allowed to be discussed except certain things which are 'bad'.
By banning discussions concerning religion.........you are in a way saying that religion forms part of the 'bad' things which i dont agree.
Am not against the decision of the board..........far from that!
I really appreciate the work you have all been doing so as to keep SF a pleasant place where peace and harmony reigns. Yet it should also be democratic.
I would suggest a poll concerning whether or not to allow discussions about religion. The participation of the whole SF family would be highly appreciated.
Still the final decision lie in the hands of the board. We'll respect any verdict of the board :)
-
We have reached a consensus that PEACEFUL discussions of religion CAN take place.
All users MUST pledge NOT to disparage other religions - if they do, an immediate ban will be placed on the individuals.
-
We have reached a consensus that PEACEFUL discussions of religion CAN take place.
All users MUST pledge NOT to disparage other religions - if they do, an immediate ban will be placed on the individuals.
Indeed this sounds a very fair decision :)
I completely agree with you............religion is not something to be used to create conflicts between members!
Punishment is fully elligible for those not abiding by these rules!
-
hmm......i kindly request the board to critically analyse the situation before reaching a verdict!
This is an open forum and anything should be allowed to be discussed except certain things which are 'bad'.
By banning discussions concerning religion.........you are in a way saying that religion forms part of the 'bad' things which i dont agree.
Am not against the decision of the board..........far from that!
I really appreciate the work you have all been doing so as to keep SF a pleasant place where peace and harmony reigns. Yet it should also be democratic.
I would suggest a poll concerning whether or not to allow discussions about religion. The participation of the whole SF family would be highly appreciated.
Still the final decision lie in the hands of the board. We'll respect any verdict of the board :)
Well expressed. +rep
-
After I spread the love*. ;D
-
After I spread the love*. ;D
I did it for you. ;)
-
I did it for you. ;)
Ooh... Thank you. ;D
That's nice. :)