So looking at ALL the girls who posted in this thread..I must assume that females don't enjoy such proposals but rather a more private and simple one.
Looking at ALL the guys who posted in that thread..most of them seem to like the idea of proposing to a girl in such way.
Conclusion :
Men like showing off, while women don't. 
Agreed!
In the book Men are from Mars and Women are From Venus, the authors pointed that typical women see what a man gives by the number of things he does for her, and not the material value of those actions--while typical men see what he's given by the material value of what he gave. For example: if a guy gives his girl a car for her birthday, he'll be like 'this must count like 50 points! I don't have to come home early for at least forty more days'. Whereas a girl will consider it
1 point, and if he doesn't come home on time for forty days that's actually -39 points xDD Things you can do for a girl don't revolve around giving gifts and taking out on expensive dates, if she really loves you anyway. A kiss on the cheek, a hug, swaying with her across the room or complimenting her count as 4 points altogether.
So yeah.
We rock.
